This year’s graduation ceremonies at University of Central Florida, University of Arizona, Middle Tennessee State University, and Glendale Community College all shared a common development: each commencement address was met with spontaneous boos and jeers from students at the exact point at which the speakers mentioned ‘artificial intelligence’ in reference to graduate futures. Far from isolated events or a flash in the pan, these students are part of the global backlash towards the rapid and unilateral expansion of AI – from chatbots to agentic systems – being imposed across every aspect of social and economic life by big tech companies operating principally out of California.
While this resistance expresses fears of a jobless future, it is by no means limited to anxieties over technological unemployment. The discourse of AI as the ‘great disrupter’ to labour market equilibrium can itself be treated as an arm of Silicon Valley ‘hype’, adjacent to baseless claims of the ‘singularity’ being only a decade away, at which point the machines will realise that humans are surplus to their needs and civilization will be on borrowed time. This particular brand of doomerism only ever seems to result in greater yield to AI infrastructures and the tech firms building them: “we simply need more investment, more researchers, more data centres, more resources, more state subsidies and more public buy-in for these technologies to be developed ethically and responsibly”.
The implication is that any other path has long been foreclosed because the very nature of this general-purpose technology itself makes artificial intelligence ‘inevitable’. This is technological determinism writ large, pushed from the highest echelons of the late capitalist order and reproduced at the base level of society.
As educators in this scenario, we are told that our only option is to jump aboard the moving train and at least try to improve the interior of the carriages and the experience of the passengers. Hence the wholesale adoption of AI within universities has been enabled not only through its managerial classes but also through the introduction of ‘AI literacy’ and ‘AI criticality’ into pedagogical practice. In treating AI as a ‘tool’ to be mastered for the purpose of ‘empowering’ learners and tending to its (still completely opaque) inner-workings with an ‘ethical’ grounding, critical AI literacy represents what Herbert Marcuse would call the repressive desublimation necessary for the agenda of big tech to further entrench itself in one of our most historically defiant social institutions, all the while questions of power and ideology are circumvented.
Members of York St John UCU branch argue: we must reject AI realism!
AI is not ‘inevitable’. It does not determine its own role in society. Behind every inevitably argument, from globalisation to AI, are political and economic interests.
‘Ethical AI’ is a misnomer. No technology predicated on hyper-exploited labour, resource depletion, and intellectual property theft can be reworked ethically.
‘AI literacy’ is a smokescreen. Its purpose is to deflate popular backlash so that it does not interfere with the commercial objectives of big tech.
Resistance is both possible and necessary. Instead of feeding the machine, we as educators must join hands with the graduates booing the tone-deaf CEOs who tell them to tolerate a future they have no agency over in practicing methods of refusal in our everyday lives.
As a trade union, YSJ UCU believes this resistance starts in the workplace. Rather than conceding to the solutionist approach, we must recognise that so-called ‘artificial intelligence’ is an elite project of extraction, expropriation and exploitation. It is not by chance that this technology is emerging at the very moment that democratic norms are under attack, fascist tendencies are resurfacing, and climate breakdown is accelerating.
Like previous ‘labour saving’ technologies adopted by capital to undermine organised labour and reproduce surplus, AI represents the mass of social labour embodied in the system of machinery. The intention of its buildout is not technological innovation for its own sake, but to create a surveillance apparatus and permission structure for those who hold enormous power and influence over social and political life to narrow the inputs of decision making even further. In the process, industry hype is leading to widespread overinvestment and overcapacity: the bubble will burst, the crash is coming.
Members of York St John UCU branch argue: we must rebel against complicity!
To develop our language of refusal, YSJ UCU is putting on a series of campus workshops over the 26/27 academic year, inviting guest speakers working on modes of resistance in their own fields to cover everything from AI and ‘edtech’ to the relationship between AI and the looming climate catastrophe. This is a call for staff and students to join the discussion and become part of the rebellion. Dates and rooms will be published in advance and we ask you to share them with colleagues and peers, in or outside the union.
On 30th September, 2:00-3:00pm in SK/037, we will be joined by Dr Joseph Choonara, lecturer in political economy at University of Leicester and author of Insecurity, Precarious Work and Labour Markets: Challenging the Orthodoxy (Springer, 2019). Dr Choonara will be talking to us about the political economy of AI in the context of recent developments inside global capitalism. The talk will be followed by questions and an open forum, and as a trade union we will take the opportunity to draw up a motion that attempts to translate the discussion into a practical form of resistance.
Members of York St John UCU branch argue: we must resist AI!
